Tutorials Point is a leading Ed Tech company striving to provide the best learning material on technical and non-technical subjects. You want to test the website on various browsers and operating systems to ensure it is compatible with all major platforms.
This can reduce the time and effort required for testing and the number of test cases that need to be written. The main advantage of Pairwise testing is that it enables the tester to identify errors that may occur when two or more different parameters are combined. This is important as errors may occur in combinations of parameters that are not tested individually. Pairwise testing, using tests that cover all 2-way combinations of parameter values, has long been accepted as a way of detecting such interaction failures [1], [2], [3], [4]. For instance, consider a failure that is triggered by unusual combinations of three or four sensor values.
On effectiveness of pairwise methodology for testing network-centric software
Feng Duan is a PhD student in Department of Computer Science and Engineering at the University of Texas at Arlington. His research interests include software analysis and testing, particularly combinatorial testing, model-based testing and input parameter modeling. Let’s say you have an application that allows users to enter two numbers, and the application will output the sum of the two numbers. You can use pairwise testing to test all possible combinations of two numbers, such as (1, 2), (2, 3), (3, 4), (4, 5), etc. By testing all the combinations of two numbers, you can be sure that the application is working correctly and will not fail when given different numbers. Raghu Kacker is a senior researcher in the Applied and Computational Mathematics Division of NIST.
Another intuitive tool for performing combinatorial testing is testcover.com where factors, values, and constraints are simply written in the editor, and test configurations are generated. This tool has an extremely fast and efficient algorithm and can generate about 15 test cases in 1 second. Another advantage is the tool’s easy generator requests where we just have to write the factors and values in new lines, that’s it! CA algorithms can produce highly compact matrices of t-way value combinations, but how does a tester decide what values to use? This approach is known as combinatorial testing (CT), an extension of the established field of statistical Design of Experiments (DoE).
Why Do We Need Combinatorial Testing Tools?
We will first try to find out the number of cases using the conventional software testing technique. We can consider the list box values as 0 and others as 0 is neither positive nor negative. Radio button and check box values cannot be reduced, so each one of them will have 2 combinations (ON or OFF). The Text box values can be reduced into three inputs (Valid Integer, Invalid Integer, Alpha-Special Character). The effectiveness of any software testing technique depends on whether test settings corresponding to the actual faults are included in the test sets. When test sets do not include settings corresponding to actual faults, the faults may not be detected.
- For instance, consider a failure that is triggered by unusual combinations of three or four sensor values.
- It can significantly reduce the number of test cases that need to be created while ensuring that all possible discrete combinations of parameters are tested.
- If a system has only a few parameters and a small number of possible values for each parameter, pairwise testing may be unnecessary.
- Another intuitive tool for performing combinatorial testing is testcover.com where factors, values, and constraints are simply written in the editor, and test configurations are generated.
- This is done by applying the all-pairs testing technique, which involves testing all possible combinations of two parameters.
Another advantage of this tool is that it can use three different algorithms (FIPOG, FIPOG-F, FIPOG-F2) to generate the combinatorial object array. So if we specify a degree of interaction of 2, ACTS will give us test sets that cover all the possible combinations of values for all the above pairs of parameters. In this example, the two variables being tested are a circle’s size (radius) and the circumference of that same circle. To test this relationship, pairwise testing would involve testing all combinations of circle sizes (radius) and corresponding circumference values. As mentioned in previous sections, CT for the purpose of software testing stems from a rich history of DoE, including designs such as OAs [12]. This previous work has had a strong influence on algorithms to generate combinatorial test suites.
Constraints Handling in CA Algorithms
In this article, we will discuss a few such tools that are available for free on the internet to generate test configurations. This example demonstrates how pairwise testing significantly reduces the number of test cases while maintaining adequate test coverage of the interactions between input parameters. For example, a program may work correctly when you input two numbers but may cause an error when you input two different numbers. By testing all possible combinations of parameters, the tester can identify these types of errors. Pairwise testing is especially useful when testing complex software with many parameters. By testing all possible combinations of parameters, the tester can ensure that no errors occur in any combination.
It operates on the principle that a majority of defects are caused by interactions between two parameters. By concentrating on testing all pairs of input values, this method uncovers defects that could be overlooked by other testing techniques. The idea behind pairwise testing is to test every possible pair of inputs. Pairwise testing reduces the number of test cases required to cover all possible combinations of input parameters, making the testing process more efficient and effective.
You would repeat this process for all of the other pairwise test cases. Richard Kuhn is a computer scientist in the Computer Security Division of the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). He has authored or coauthored 2 books and more than 100 publications on information security, empirical studies of software failure, and software assurance, and is a senior member of the IEEE. Before joining NIST, he worked as a systems analyst with NCR Corporation and the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory. He received an MS in Computer Science from the University of Maryland, College Park, and an MBA from the College of William & Mary.
This means that all possible combinations of line lengths are being tested to ensure the accuracy of the length measurement. For example, the length of a line segment could be 1 unit, 2 units, 3 units, or 4 units, so all possible combinations of these lengths must be tested to ensure accuracy. This allows for detecting any discrepancies or errors in the measurement of the line segment. This tool gives a bit more functionality and features as compared to the previous tool. Firstly, it allows us to create multiple input parameter models instead of just one like in the previous tool. Also, we can save these models as well and export them to a different type of files.
For thorough checking, it may be necessary to test 3-way and 4-way combinations of values. The question arises as to whether testing all 4-way combinations is enough to detect all errors. What is the distribution of interaction failures beyond 2-way in real systems? Surprisingly, this question had not been studied when NIST began investigating interaction failures in 1999 [5].
Pairwise testing relies on all pairs of parameters interacting to determine the results, and sometimes, this assumption may be false. Incorrect assumptions like this can prevent bugs from being caught in testing. In this section, we will be discussing some easy-to-use, free, and popular combinatorial testing tools. Use Case testing is a functional testing method that verifies the software’s behavior based on real-life scenarios or use cases. Testers create test cases derived from use cases specified during the software requirements analysis phase. Once you have the generated test cases, you can also automate them via some black box testing tool like Testsigma.
Conversely, we can be confident that the software works correctly for t-way combinations contained in passing tests. When the tests are derived from t-way CAs, we know that 100% of the t-way combinations have been tested. Since combinatorial testing follows a complex procedure and it can be a tedious task to manually perform this testing https://www.globalcloudteam.com/ on many input parameters, we, therefore, use combinatorial testing tools. Not only are these tools easy to use with many input parameters, but they can also add constraints in the input parameters and generate test configurations accordingly. There are numerous tools available on the internet to perform combinatorial testing.
He has contributed to design and evaluation of industrial experiments, quality engineering, and evaluation of measurement uncertainty in physical measurements and in outputs of computational models. His current interests include development and use of combinatorial mathematics methods for testing software systems. He is a Fellow of the American Statistical Association and a Fellow of the American Society for Quality. He has also worked in industry (AT&T Bell Telephone Laboratories) and academia (Virginia Tech, Blacksburg, VA).
Apart from these, the clients and users also demand exponential performance, functionality, quality, scalability, effectiveness, and more. Moreover, it can also cause bodily harm, which can result in large economic losses or security breaches, as well as affect the quality of day-to-day life. However, software testers often have limited time and budget, which frequently makes it impossible to exhaustively test software. Additionally, testers often intuitively test for defects that they anticipate, while less foreseen defects are overlooked and not tested. The best way to overcome such a situation is to implement Combinatorial Testing in software and applications.